Photo by Stephen Buchanan
Since 2017, owner Rik Squillari has drawn crowds to his Italian tavern, which is located off the beaten track from the Annapolis dining scene. Harvest Thyme in Davidsonville offers seasonal menus, creative offerings, plus Italian standards, which keep people coming back for cuisine made with effort and care.
Harvest Thyme deserves very high marks for its ambitious adaptation to the challenging COVID months, keeping up with many of its popular traditions like its extensive pizza menu, and also with its more complex offerings like the starter and entrees we chose this night. We also lucked out with exceptionally unusual Fall weather, which extended their highly suitable outdoor dining spread along the petite strip mall’s sidewalks—just the right size tables and overhead lighting. Patio heaters at the ready assure outdoor comfort. Inside, business was brisk too, with tables adequately spread apart.
We laughed at ourselves for stumbling a bit over a restaurant first; pointing our cell phones at the QR (quick response) code pasted on our table to access the menu—a novel safety step to eliminate the risk of disposable or sanitized menu. Don’t forget your reading glasses.
Squillari takes pride in his wine offerings, as he should since he spent years in the business. With a unique formula, he offers bottled wine at retail prices, rather than restaurant markup, with a $10 corkage fee. An entire wall of the interior is devoted to wine and bottles are available for purchase as are beers and spirits. The menu sports a simple but very nice selection of both reds and whites by the glass and an extensive list of bottles, which several tables around us were enjoying. My companion chose the Pinot Noir, currently an interesting one from Angels Ink, new on the menu since our last visit. The Angels Ink hails from multiple Central Coast (CA) vineyards and complemented the meal well. It’s on the light side, fruit-forward with berries and vanilla and a nice note from its oak aging. (Note that at the time of our visit, there were four other Pinot Noir choices by the bottle, and you can make a purchase in the retail shop, to be opened tableside for the corkage fee.)
If you prefer cocktails or beer, don’t miss the options here. There are numerous craft beers, including a flight of draft beers, and creative cocktails, some with ingredients like local cider.
We had peeked at the menu before arriving and were ready to go with the evening’s appetizer special; a trio of beautifully plump sea scallops in a lovely fennel, apple brandy cream sauce. Even without a specific seafood focus, Harvest Thyme knows where to source its scallops. Absolutely the freshest and sublimely cooked—a feat that many eateries haven’t perfected. The fennel apple brandy sauce was novel and appropriately light. Our one wish for this otherwise wonderful starter was a lighter touch with the salt. The dish paired beautifully with a glass of Bohigas Cava from Catalunya, Spain. Fruity with hints of cinnamon, this sparkling wine has a light sugar content and feels dry, soft, and creamy. A festive way to begin the evening.
When last we were at Harvest Thyme we ate inside and after sitting through the aroma of pizza baking, we vowed we would come back and try one. So here we were ordering the Woodcutter Pizza featuring Sweet Italian Sausage, Applewood Bacon, and Wild Mushrooms. The crisp browned sausage and bacon were the stars on this pizza pie with a smear of tomato sauce and light sprinkling of cheese.
Photos by Stephen Buchanan
The day’s catch enticed me to try and it arrived as an enticing slab (rather than a filet) of Chilean Seabass leaning upon a bed of creamy polenta. The rich bacon and tomato reduction was a thick deep red sauce served in a side tiny crock with baby carrots as a vegetable. The half-inch thick steak of fin fish had a golden surface and was delightfully moist in the center.
My dining companion couldn’t decide at first between two Italian-leaning entrees: would it be the Pear and Ricotta Sacchetti or the special Braised Short Rib Ravioli? If “sacchetti” is new to you, it translates to beggar’s purses and sounds charming, especially as it’s served here with taleggio, prosciutto, and basil cream sauce. But the winner this night was the Ravioli with its most-exotic sounding flair: wild Hen of the Woods Mushroom Demi-Glace Cream, topped with Venison Ragout and Fresh Herbs. Definitely a dish to leave to the experts at Harvest Thyme. We learned that the complex demi-glace consists of veal bones cooked in stock for 24 hours and then reduced to a “master” base sauce for the other ingredients. Very unusual and delicious, and a most generous serving of very fresh tasting raviolis.
Supremely satisfied, we still wanted a taste of something sweet and decided on the Peanut Butter Pie, which was described as an immense Reese’s Peanut Butter cup. It was a thick wedge of what tasted like peanut butter cheesecake on rich chocolate cookie crumb crust finished by a quarter-inch thick fudge ganache top layer. The rosette of whipped cream garnished the opulent dessert. The excellent decaf coffee deserves a nod—I almost never like after dinner coffee anywhere and this really was good—enough to ask for a refill.
Harvest Thyme Tavern 1251 West Central Avenue, Davidsonville | 443-203-6846 | harvestthymetavern.com
